A Generator Framework For Evolving Variant-Rich Software

TL;DR

This paper introduces vpbench, a modular framework that automatically generates detailed, realistic source-code histories of variant-rich software systems to facilitate better evaluation of evolution management tools.

Contribution

The paper presents vpbench, a novel framework for generating comprehensive, realistic evolution histories of variant-rich software, addressing evaluation gaps in existing research.

Findings

Vpbench can generate detailed source-code evolution histories.

It supports evolution in both time and space dimensions.

The framework includes simple and advanced generation techniques.

Abstract

Evolving software is challenging, even more when it exists in many different variants. Such software evolves not only in time, but also in space--another dimension of complexity. While evolution in space is supported by a variety of product-line and variability management tools, many of which originating from research, their level of evaluation varies significantly, which threatens their relevance for practitioners and future research. Many tools have only been evaluated on ad hoc datasets, minimal examples or available preprocessor-based product lines, missing the early clone & own phases and the re-engineering into configurable platforms--large parts of the actual evolution lifecycle of variant-rich systems. Our long-term goal is to provide benchmarks to increase the maturity of evaluating such tools. However, providing manually curated benchmarks that cover the whole evolution lifecycle and that are detailed enough to serve as ground truths, is challenging. We present the framework vpbench to generates source-code histories of variant-rich systems. Vpbench comprises several modular generators relying on evolution operators that systematically and automatically evolve real codebases and document the evolution in detail. We provide simple and more advanced generators--e.g., relying on code transplantation techniques to obtain whole features from external, real-world projects. We define requirements and demonstrate how vpbench addresses them for the generated version histories, focusing on support for evolution in time and space, the generation of detailed meta-data about the evolution, also considering compileability and extensibility.