An Exact Method for Fortification Games

TL;DR

This paper introduces an exact solution method for fortification games, a complex three-level Stackelberg game, using a new mixed-integer linear programming reformulation and fortification cuts, enabling optimal solutions for previously unsolvable instances.

Contribution

The work develops a novel branch-and-cut algorithm with fortification cuts for fortification games, improving solution efficiency and solving previously intractable problems.

Findings

Algorithm outperforms existing methods in computational tests.

Successfully solves previously unsolved instances to optimality.

Demonstrates effectiveness on knapsack and shortest path fortification games.

Abstract

A fortification game (FG) is a three-level, two-player Stackelberg game, also known as defender-attacker-defender game, in which at the uppermost level, the defender selects some assets to be protected from potential malicious attacks. At the middle level, the attacker solves an interdiction game by depreciating unprotected assets, i.e., reducing the values of such assets for the defender, while at the innermost level the defender solves a recourse problem over the surviving or partially damaged assets. Fortification games have applications in various important areas, such as military operations, design of survivable networks, protection of facilities, or power grid protection. In this work, we present an exact solution algorithm for FGs, in which the recourse problems correspond to (possibly NP-hard) combinatorial optimization problems. The algorithm is based on a new generic mixed-integer linear programming reformulation in the natural space of fortification variables. Our new model makes use of fortification cuts that measure the contribution of a given fortification strategy to the objective function value. These cuts are generated on-the-fly by solving separation problems, which correspond to (modified) middle-level interdiction games. We design a branch-and-cut-based solution algorithm based on fortification cuts, their lifted versions, and other speed-up techniques. We present a computational study using the knapsack fortification game and the shortest path fortification game. For the latter one, we include a comparison with a state-of-the-art solution method from the literature. Our algorithm outperforms this method and allows us to solve previously unsolved instances to optimality.