A Transient Semantics for Typed Racket

TL;DR

This paper explores applying Transient semantics to a rich migratory type system like Typed Racket, revealing implementation challenges and performance trade-offs, and providing insights for language designers and theoreticians.

Contribution

It demonstrates the difficulties of adapting Transient semantics to a complex migratory type system and offers practical guidance for implementing Transient checks in such languages.

Findings

Transient blame strategy is problematic in rich migratory systems.

Shallow Typed Racket outperforms Deep Typed Racket when blame checks are disabled.

Adapting Transient semantics requires careful consideration of blame strategies.

Abstract

Mixed-typed languages enable programmers to link typed and untyped components in various ways. Some offer rich type systems to facilitate the smooth migration of untyped code to the typed world; others merely provide a convenient form of type Dynamic together with a conventional structural type system. Orthogonal to this dimension, Natural systems ensure the integrity of types with a sophisticated contract system, while Transient systems insert simple first-order checks at strategic places within typed code. Furthermore, each method of ensuring type integrity comes with its own blame-assignment strategy. Typed Racket has a rich migratory type system and enforces the types with a Natural semantics. Reticulated Python has a simple structural type system extended with Dynamic and enforces types with a Transient semantics. While Typed Racket satisfies the most stringent gradual-type soundness properties at a significant performance cost, Reticulated Python seems to limit the performance penalty to a tolerable degree and is nevertheless type sound. This comparison raises the question of whether Transient checking is applicable to and beneficial for a rich migratory type system. This paper reports on the surprising difficulties of adapting the Transient semantics of Reticulated Python to the rich migratory type system of Typed Racket. The resulting implementation, Shallow Typed Racket, is faster than the standard Deep Typed Racket but only when the Transient blame assignment strategy is disabled. For language designers, this report provides valuable hints on how to equip an existing compiler to support a Transient semantics. For theoreticians, the negative experience with Transient blame calls for a thorough investigation of this strategy.