Sampling Molecular Gas in the Helix Planetary Nebula: Variation in HNC/HCN with UV Flux

TL;DR

This study investigates how UV radiation influences the HNC/HCN molecular ratio in the Helix planetary nebula, revealing that UV flux impacts molecular abundances but does not solely explain their variation.

Contribution

It provides the first detections of HCN, HNC, and other molecules in Helix knots and analyzes the role of UV radiation in molecular abundance variations using observational data and photodissociation models.

Findings

HNC/HCN ratio increases with distance from the central star

HNC/HCN ratio is anticorrelated with UV emission across the nebula

UV flux alone cannot fully explain the observed molecular ratio variations

Abstract

Observations of molecular clouds, prestellar cores, and protoplanetary disks have established that the HNC/HCN ratio may be a potent diagnostic of molecular gas physical conditions. The processes that govern the relative abundances of these molecules nevertheless remain poorly understood. We seek to exploit the wide range of UV irradiation strengths within the 1 pc diameter Helix planetary nebula to explore the potential role of UV radiation in driving HNC/HCN. We performed IRAM 30 m and APEX 12 m radio line observations across six positions within the Helix Nebula, making use of radiative transfer and photodissociation modeling codes to interpret the results for line intensities and line ratios in terms of the molecular gas properties. We have obtained the first detections of the plasma-embedded Helix molecular knots (globules) in HCN, HNC, HCO+, and other trace molecules. Analysis of the HNC/HCN integrated line intensity ratio reveals an increase with radial distance from the Helix central star. In the context of molecular line ratios of other planetary nebulae from the literature, the HNC/HCN ratio appears to be anticorrelated with UV emission over four orders of magnitude in incident flux. Models of the photodissociation regions within the Helix using the RADEX and Meudon codes reveal strong constraints on column density of the molecular gas, as well as pressure and temperature. Analysis of the molecular ion HCO+ across the Helix indicates that X-ray irradiation is likely driving HCO+ production in the outer regions of planetary nebulae, where photodissociation is limited, yet cold gas and ionized molecules are abundant. Although the observational results clearly indicate that UV irradiation is important in determining the HNC/HCN ratio, our PDR modeling indicates that the UV flux gradient alone cannot reproduce the observed variation of HNC/HCN across the Helix.