Evidence of a Phonon Hall Effect in the Kitaev Spin Liquid Candidate $\alpha$-RuCl$_3$

TL;DR

This study suggests that the observed thermal Hall effect in $ ext{RuCl}_3$ is primarily due to phonons, challenging the interpretation that it indicates Majorana fermions in the Kitaev quantum spin liquid state.

Contribution

The paper provides evidence that the thermal Hall conductivity in $ ext{RuCl}_3$ is mainly phononic, questioning previous claims of Majorana fermion detection in this material.

Findings

$ ext{κ}_{xy}$ closely follows $ ext{κ}_{xx}$ temperature dependence.

$ ext{κ}_{xy}$ increases below the magnetic ordering temperature $T_N$.

Phonons are the dominant carriers of the thermal Hall effect in $ ext{RuCl}_3$.

Abstract

The material $\alpha$-RuCl$_3$ has been the subject of intense scrutiny as a potential Kitaev quantum spin liquid, predicted to display Majorana fermions as low energy excitations. In practice, $\alpha$-RuCl$_3$ undergoes a transition to a state with antiferromagnetic order below a temperature $T_{\rm N}$ $\approx$ 7 K, but this order can be suppressed by applying an external in-plane magnetic field of $H_\parallel$ = 7 T. Whether a quantum spin liquid phase exists just above that field is still an open question, but the reported observation of a quantized thermal Hall conductivity at $H_\parallel$ $>$ 7 T by Kasahara and co-workers $\big[$Kasahara ${\it et \ al}$., Nature ${\bf 559}$, 227 (2018)$\big]$ has been interpreted as evidence of itinerant Majorana fermions in the Kitaev quantum spin liquid state. In this study, we re-examine the origin of the thermal Hall conductivity $\kappa_{\rm xy}$ in $\alpha$-RuCl$_3$. Our measurements of $\kappa_{\rm xy}$($T$) on several different crystals yield a temperature dependence very similar to that of the phonon-dominated longitudinal thermal conductivity $\kappa_{\rm xx}$($T$), for which the natural explanation is that $\kappa_{\rm xy}$ is also mostly carried by phonons. Upon cooling, $\kappa_{\rm xx}$ peaks at $T \simeq$ 20 K, then drops until $T_{\rm N}$, whereupon it suddenly increases again. The abrupt increase below $T_{\rm N}$ is attributed to a sudden reduction in the scattering of phonons by low-energy spin fluctuations as these become partially gapped when the system orders. The fact that $\kappa_{\rm xy}$ also increases suddenly below $T_{\rm N}$ is strong evidence that the thermal Hall effect in $\alpha$-RuCl$_3$ is also carried predominantly by phonons. This implies that any quantized signal from Majorana edge modes would have to come on top of a sizable -- and sample-dependent -- phonon background.