A comprehensive assessment of accuracy of adaptive integration of cut cells for laminar fluid-structure interaction problems

TL;DR

This paper evaluates the accuracy and computational efficiency of adaptive cut-cell integration techniques in fluid-structure interaction simulations, demonstrating that limited refinement levels suffice for reliable results in laminar flows.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive assessment of adaptive integration in cut-cell methods, identifying optimal refinement levels for accurate and efficient FSI simulations.

Findings

Three levels of adaptive refinement are sufficient for accurate force and displacement calculations.

Adaptive integration accuracy significantly influences convergence rates in velocity and pressure fields.

Fewer refinement levels reduce computational cost while maintaining acceptable accuracy.

Abstract

Finite element methods based on cut-cells are becoming increasingly popular because of their advantages over formulations based on body-fitted meshes for problems with moving interfaces. In such methods, the cells (or elements) which are cut by the interface between two different domains need to be integrated using special techniques in order to obtain optimal convergence rates and accurate fluxes across the interface. The adaptive integration technique in which the cells are recursively subdivided is one of the popular techniques for the numerical integration of cut-cells due to its advantages over tessellation, particularly for problems involving complex geometries in three dimensions. Although adaptive integration does not impose any limitations on the representation of the geometry of immersed solids as it requires only point location algorithms, it becomes computationally expensive for recovering optimal convergence rates. This paper presents a comprehensive assessment of the adaptive integration of cut-cells for applications in computational fluid dynamics and fluid-structure interaction. We assess the effect of the accuracy of integration of cut cells on convergence rates in velocity and pressure fields, and then on forces and displacements for fluid-structure interaction problems by studying several examples in two and three dimensions. By taking the computational cost and the accuracy of forces and displacements into account, we demonstrate that numerical results of acceptable accuracy for FSI problems involving laminar flows can be obtained with only fewer levels of refinement. In particular, we show that three levels of adaptive refinement are sufficient for obtaining force and displacement values of acceptable accuracy for laminar fluid-structure interaction problems.