Algorithms and data structures for first-order logic with connectivity under vertex failures

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new data structure for efficiently answering connectivity queries in graphs with vertex failures and explores the logical complexity of such problems within separator logic, establishing fixed-parameter tractability results.

Contribution

The authors present the first deterministic data structure for connectivity under vertex failures with fixed failures answered in constant time and analyze the model-checking problem for separator logic on minor-free graph classes.

Findings

Constant-time connectivity queries for fixed vertex failures.

Fixed-parameter tractability of separator logic model-checking on minor-free graphs.

A decomposition theorem enabling reduction of separator logic to first-order logic.

Abstract

We introduce a new data structure for answering connectivity queries in undirected graphs subject to batched vertex failures. Precisely, given any graph G and integer k, we can in fixed-parameter time construct a data structure that can later be used to answer queries of the form: ``are vertices s and t connected via a path that avoids vertices $u_1,..., u_k$?'' in time $2^{2^{O(k)}}$. In the terminology of the literature on data structures, this gives the first deterministic data structure for connectivity under vertex failures where for every fixed number of failures, all operations can be performed in constant time. With the aim to understand the power and the limitations of our new techniques, we prove an algorithmic meta theorem for the recently introduced separator logic, which extends first-order logic with atoms for connectivity under vertex failures. We prove that the model-checking problem for separator logic is fixed-parameter tractable on every class of graphs that exclude a fixed topological minor. We also show a weak converse. This implies that from the point of view of parameterized complexity, under standard complexity assumptions, the frontier of tractability of separator logic is almost exactly delimited by classes excluding a fixed topological minor. The backbone of our proof relies on a decomposition theorem of Cygan et al. [SICOMP '19], which provides a tree decomposition of a given graph into bags that are unbreakable. Crucially, unbreakability allows to reduce separator logic to plain first-order logic within each bag individually. We design our model-checking algorithm using dynamic programming over the tree decomposition, where the transition at each bag amounts to running a suitable model-checking subprocedure for plain first-order logic. This approach is robust enough to provide also efficient enumeration of queries expressed in separator logic.