The role of asymmetries in coronal rain formation during thermal non-equilibrium cycles

TL;DR

This study investigates how asymmetries in coronal loops influence the formation of coronal rain during thermal non-equilibrium cycles, revealing that symmetry in heating and geometry favors rain formation.

Contribution

It demonstrates through extensive simulations that loop and heating asymmetries critically determine coronal rain occurrence during TNE cycles, unifying observations of rain and non-rain events.

Findings

Coronal rain formation depends on loop and heating symmetry.

Symmetric loops with symmetric heating are more likely to produce rain.

Asymmetric loops require compensating heating asymmetry for rain formation.

Abstract

Context: Thermal non-equilibrium (TNE) produces several observables that can be used to constrain the spatial and temporal distribution of solar coronal heating. Its manifestations include prominence formation, coronal rain, and long-period intensity pulsations in coronal loops. The recent observation of abundant periodic coronal rain associated with intensity pulsations by Auch\`ere et al. allows to unify these two phenomena as the result of TNE condensation and evaporation cycles. On the other hand, many intensity pulsation events observed by Froment et al. show little to no coronal rain formation. Aims: Our goal is to understand why some TNE cycles produce such abundant coronal rain, while others produce little to no rain. Methods: We reconstruct the geometry of the event reported by Auch\`ere et al., using images from STEREO/SECCHI/EUVI and magnetograms from SDO/HMI. We then perform 1D hydrodynamic simulations of this event, for different heating parameters and variations of the loop geometry (9000 simulations in total). We compare the resulting behaviour to simulations of TNE cycles by Froment et al. that do not produce coronal rain. Results: Our simulations show that both prominences and TNE cycles (with and without coronal rain) can form within the same magnetic structure. We show that the formation of coronal rain during TNE cycles depends on the asymmetry of the loop and of the heating. Asymmetric loops are overall less likely to produce coronal rain, regardless of the heating. In symmetric loops, coronal rain forms when the heating is also symmetric. In asymmetric loops, rain forms only when the heating compensates the asymmetry.