Turbulent drag reduction of viscoelastic wormlike micellar gels

TL;DR

This study experimentally investigates turbulent flow of viscoelastic wormlike micellar gels, revealing their breakdown under turbulence, drag reduction effects comparable to polymers, and similar mechanisms at maximum drag reduction conditions.

Contribution

It provides new experimental insights into the turbulent behavior and drag reduction mechanisms of wormlike micellar gels, a less-studied class of viscoelastic fluids.

Findings

Wormlike micellar gels break down under turbulence, especially near walls.

Higher surfactant concentrations lead to drag reduction and altered turbulence spectra.

Maximum drag reduction in micellar gels is similar to that in polymer solutions, following Virk's asymptote.

Abstract

Long-chained, viscoelastic surfactant solutions (VES) have been widely employed in the oil and gas industry, particularly in hydraulic fracturing and gravel-packing operations, where turbulence is commonly reached due to high pumping rates. With this motivation, we experimentally investigate the turbulent duct flow of an under-studied class of wormlike micellar solutions that forms a gel at room temperature. The fluid is characterized via rotational rheometry, and the turbulent velocity and Reynolds stress profiles are measured via Laser Doppler Anemometry (LDA). Three surfactant concentrations are investigated at increasing Reynolds numbers. The turbulent flow fields of water, and semi-dilute solutions of partially hydrolyzed polyacrylamide (HPAM) and xanthan gum (XG) are used as comparisons. Our study reveals that the gel-like structure of the wormlike micellar gel is mostly broken down during turbulent flow, especially in the near-wall region where the results indicate the presence of a water layer. Turbulent flow at low concentrations of surfactant show a Newtonian-like flow field throughout most of the duct, where the energy spectra shows a -5/3 power law scale with wavenumber, whereas higher concentrations lead to drag reduction and lower power spectral densities at large wavenumbers. A comparison of the flow of polymeric fluids and the wormlike micellar solutions at maximum drag reduction (MDR) shows comparable drag-reduction effects, with a large decrease in Reynolds shear stresses, and increased turbulence anisotropy in the buffer layer due to the large streamwise fluctuations and near-zero wall-normal fluctuations. Additionally, the MDR regime was bounded by Virk's asymptote for both polymers and the micellar gel, which implies a similar mechanism of drag reduction at MDR.