A Simple Numerical Method for Evaluating Heat Dissipation from Curved Wires with Periodic Applied Heating

TL;DR

This paper introduces a straightforward numerical approach to evaluate heat dissipation from curved wires with periodic heating, extending the three-omega method to non-straight geometries and quantifying systematic errors.

Contribution

The authors present a general numerical method for calculating temperature distributions in arbitrarily curved heating wires, improving accuracy in thermal conductivity measurements.

Findings

Curved wires with gentle bends show less than 12% deviation from straight-wire predictions.

The straight-line source solution is accurate for bends greater than 45°.

The method helps quantify systematic errors due to wire geometry in thermal measurements.

Abstract

In many situations, the dual-purpose heater/thermometer wires used in the three-omega method, one of the most precise and sensitive techniques for measuring the thermal conductivity of thin films and interfaces, must include bends and curves to avoid obstructions on the surface of a sample. Although the three-omega analysis assumes that the heating wire is infinitely long and straight, recent experimental work has demonstrated that in some cases curved-wire geometries can be used without introducing detectable systematic error. We describe a general numerical method that can be used to calculate the temperature of three-omega heating wires with arbitrary wire geometries. This method provides experimentalists with a simple quantitative procedure for calculating how large the systematic error caused by a particular wire asymmetry will be. We show calculations of two useful cases: a straight wire with a single bend of arbitrary angle and a wire that forms a circle. We find that the amplitude of the in-phase temperature oscillations near a wire that forms a circle differs from the prediction using the analytic straight-line source solution by $<$12%, provided that the thermal penetration depth is less than ten times the radius of curvature of the wire path. The in-phase temperature amplitude 1.5 wire widths away from a 90$^{\circ}$ bend in a wire is within 11% of the straight-line source prediction for all penetration depths greater than the wire width. Our calculations indicate that the straight-line source solution breaks down significantly when the wire bend angle is less than 45$^{\circ}$.