#ContextMatters: Advantages and Limitations of Using Machine Learning to Support Women in Politics

TL;DR

This paper evaluates ParityBOT, a natural language processing tool deployed during elections in three countries, to analyze and counter online toxicity against women in politics, highlighting its benefits and current limitations.

Contribution

The paper introduces ParityBOT, the first NLP-based intervention aimed at reducing online toxicity towards women in politics and discusses its deployment and challenges across multiple countries.

Findings

ParityBOT analyzed over 12 million tweets targeting women candidates.

The system missed obvious insults, indicating false negatives.

Microaggressions have unaddressed harms impacting women and gender equality.

Abstract

The United Nations identified gender equality as a Sustainable Development Goal in 2015, recognizing the underrepresentation of women in politics as a specific barrier to achieving gender equality. Political systems around the world experience gender inequality across all levels of elected government as fewer women run for office than men. This is due in part to online abuse, particularly on social media platforms like Twitter, where women seeking or in power tend to be targeted with more toxic maltreatment than their male counterparts. In this paper, we present reflections on ParityBOT - the first natural language processing-based intervention designed to affect online discourse for women in politics for the better, at scale. Deployed across elections in Canada, the United States and New Zealand, ParityBOT was used to analyse and classify more than 12 million tweets directed at women candidates and counter toxic tweets with supportive ones. From these elections we present three case studies highlighting the current limitations of, and future research and application opportunities for, using a natural language processing-based system to detect online toxicity, specifically with regards to contextually important microaggressions. We examine the rate of false negatives, where ParityBOT failed to pick up on insults directed at specific high profile women, which would be obvious to human users. We examine the unaddressed harms of microaggressions and the potential of yet unseen damage they cause for women in these communities, and for progress towards gender equality overall, in light of these technological blindspots. This work concludes with a discussion on the benefits of partnerships between nonprofit social groups and technology experts to develop responsible, socially impactful approaches to addressing online hate.