CMB lensing reconstruction biases from masking extragalactic sources

TL;DR

This paper investigates how masking extragalactic sources in CMB maps introduces biases in lensing measurements, quantifies these biases, and proposes mitigation strategies, with implications for future cosmological analyses and cluster mass calibration.

Contribution

It provides a detailed analysis of mask-induced biases in CMB lensing reconstruction, including analytic models and simulation tests, highlighting their significance and methods for reduction.

Findings

Masking extragalactic sources can bias lensing auto- and cross-correlation spectra.

Optimal filtering significantly reduces mask-induced biases.

Biases from tSZ-selected clusters are potentially detectable with high significance.

Abstract

Observed Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) maps are contaminated by foregrounds, some of which are usually masked to perform cosmological analyses. If masks are correlated to the lensing signal, such as those removing extragalactic emissions located in matter overdensities, measurements over the unmasked sky may give biased estimates. We quantify the impact of these mask-induced biases for the reconstructed CMB lensing auto- and cross-correlation power spectra with external matter tracers. We show that they arise both from changes in the lensing power, and via modifications to the reconstruction power spectrum corrections, $N_L^{(0)}$, $N_L^{(1)}$ and $N_L^{(3/2)}$). For direct masking of the CMB lensing field, we derive simple analytic models of the masking effect and show that it is potentially large. We show that mask-induced biases are significantly reduced by optimal filtering of the CMB maps in the lensing reconstruction. We test the resulting lensing power spectrum biases on numerical simulations, masking radio sources, and peaks of thermal Sunyaev-Zeldovich (tSZ) and cosmic infrared background (CIB) emission. For the lensing auto spectrum, masking biases can only be measured with a statistical significance $\lesssim 3\sigma$ for future data sets. The same applies to the cross-correlation power spectra between CMB lensing and tSZ and CIB even though biases are larger (up to ~30%). We find that masking tSZ-selected galaxy clusters leads to the largest mask biases, potentially detectable with high significance. We find that the calibration of cluster masses using CMB lensing, in particular for objects at $z\lesssim 0.6$, might be significantly affected by mask biases for near-future observations if the lensing signal recovered inside the mask holes is used without further corrections. Conversely, mass calibration of high redshift objects will still deliver unbiased results.