Macroscopic delayed-choice and retrocausality: quantum eraser, Leggett-Garg and dimension witness tests with cat states

TL;DR

This paper explores macroscopic delayed-choice experiments using cat states, demonstrating violations of classical realism and suggesting the necessity of extra dimensions or non-retrocausal interpretations in quantum mechanics.

Contribution

It introduces a framework for macroscopic delayed-choice experiments with cat states, analyzing violations of macroscopic realism and proposing interpretations avoiding retrocausality.

Findings

Violations of Leggett-Garg and dimension witness inequalities with macroscopic states.

Demonstration of quantum eraser with delayed choice on macroscopic qubits.

Evidence that classical models cannot fully explain the observed quantum phenomena.

Abstract

We propose delayed choice experiments carried out with macroscopic qubits, realised as macroscopically-distinct coherent states $|\alpha\rangle$ and $|-\alpha\rangle$. Quantum superpositions of $|\alpha\rangle$ and $|-\alpha\rangle$ are created via a unitary interaction $U(\theta)$ based on a nonlinear Hamiltonian. Macroscopic delayed-choice experiments give a compelling reason to develop interpretations not allowing macroscopic retrocausality (MrC). We therefore consider weak macroscopic realism (wMR), which specifies a hidden variable $\lambda_{\theta}$ to determine the macroscopic qubit value (analogous to 'which-way' information), independent of any future measurement setting $\phi$. Using entangled states, we demonstrate a quantum eraser where the choice to measure a which-way or wave-type property is delayed. Consistency with wMR is possible, if we interpret the macroscopic qubit value to be determined by $\lambda_{\theta}$ without specification of the state at the level of $\hbar$, where fringes manifest. We then demonstrate violations of a delayed-choice Leggett-Garg inequality, and of the dimension witness inequality applied to the Wheeler-Chaves-Lemos-Pienaar experiment, where measurements need only distinguish the macroscopic qubit states. This negates all two-dimensional non-retrocausal models, thereby suggesting MrC. However, one can interpret consistently with wMR, thus avoiding MrC, by noting extra dimensions, and by noting that the violations require further unitary dynamics $U$ for each system. The violations are then explained as failure of deterministic macroscopic realism (dMR), which specifies validity of $\lambda_{\theta}$ prior to the dynamics $U(\theta)$ determining the measurement setting $\theta$. Finally, although there is consistency with wMR for macroscopic observations, we demonstrate EPR paradoxes at a microscopic level.