Simultaneous Matrix Orderings for Graph Collections

TL;DR

This paper introduces a collection-aware approach for simultaneously ordering adjacency matrices of multiple graphs, improving visualization quality by preserving more information and using Moran's I as a comprehensive quality metric.

Contribution

It proposes a novel collection-aware heuristic for matrix ordering that avoids information loss and employs Moran's I for better pattern detection in graph collections.

Findings

Collection-aware approach outperforms union-based methods.

Moran's I captures a wider range of patterns than traditional metrics.

Our method consistently improves ordering quality on real-world datasets.

Abstract

Undirected graphs are frequently used to model networks. The topology of an undirected graph G can be captured by an adjacency matrix; this matrix in turn can be visualized directly to give insight into the graph structure. Which visual patterns appear in such a matrix visualization depends on the ordering of its rows and columns. Formally defining the quality of an ordering and then automatically computing a high-quality ordering are both challenging problems; however, effective heuristics exist and are used in practice. Often, graphs exist as part of a collection of graphs on the same set of vertices. To visualize such graph collections, we need a single ordering that works well for all matrices simultaneously. The current state-of-the-art solves this problem by taking a (weighted) union over all graphs and applying existing heuristics. However, this union leads to a loss of information, specifically in those parts of the graphs which are different. We propose a collection-aware approach to avoid this loss of information and apply it to two popular heuristic methods: leaf order and barycenter. The de-facto standard computational quality metrics for matrix ordering capture only block-diagonal patterns (cliques). Instead, we propose to use Moran's I, a spatial auto-correlation metric, which captures the full range of established patterns. The popular leaf order method heuristically optimizes a similar measure which supports the use of Moran's I in this context. We evaluated our methods for simultaneous orderings on real-world datasets using Moran's I as the quality metric. Our results show that our collection-aware approach matches or improves performance compared to the union approach, depending on the similarity of the graphs in the collection. Specifically, our Moran's I-based collection-aware leaf order implementation consistently outperforms other implementations.