Internal Feedback in Biological Control: Diversity, Delays, and Standard Theory

TL;DR

This paper explores how internal feedback pathways in biological control systems, especially delays and diversity, are crucial for optimal performance, demonstrated through a case study on control with diverse sensors and delays.

Contribution

It reveals the fundamental role of internal feedback pathways in biological control architectures and introduces the diversity-enabled sweet spot (DESS) concept through a case study.

Findings

Controllers with diverse sensors outperform single-sensor controllers.

Internal feedback pathways enable the diversity-enabled sweet spot (DESS).

Delays impair controllers lacking internal feedback pathways.

Abstract

Neural architectures in organisms support efficient and robust control that is beyond the capability of engineered architectures. Unraveling the function of such architectures is challenging; their components are highly diverse and heterogeneous in their morphology, physiology, and biochemistry, and often obey severe speed-accuracy tradeoffs; they also contain many cryptic internal feedback pathways (IFPs). We claim that IFPs are crucial architectural features that strategically combine highly diverse components to give rise to optimal performance. We demonstrate this in a case study, and additionally describe how sensing and actuation delays in standard control (state feedback, full control, output feedback) give rise to independent and separable sources of IFPs. Our case study is an LQR problem with two types of sensors, one fast but sparse and one dense but slow. Controllers using only one type of sensor perform poorly, often failing even to stabilize; controllers using both types of sensors perform extremely well, demonstrating a strong diversity-enabled sweet spot (DESS). We demonstrate that IFPs are key in enabling this DESS, and additionally that with IFPs removed, controllers with delayed sensing perform poorly. The existence of strong DESS and IFP in this simple example suggest that these are fundamental architectural features in any complex system with diverse components, such as organisms and cyberphysical systems.