Comparative Analysis of Cryptographic Key Management Systems

TL;DR

This paper compares five cryptographic key management systems, evaluating their features, security, and performance to guide organizations in selecting suitable solutions.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive comparison of key management tools based on implementation complexity, security, and technical performance, aiding enterprise decision-making.

Findings

Hashicorp Vault is most suitable for small businesses.

Vault demonstrated the best response time and network efficiency.

The systems vary in security features and ease of implementation.

Abstract

Managing cryptographic keys can be a complex task for an enterprise and particularly difficult to scale when an increasing number of users and applications need to be managed. In order to address scalability issues, typical IT infrastructures employ key management systems that are able to handle a large number of encryption keys and associate them with the authorized requests. Given their necessity, recent years have witnessed a variety of key management systems, aligned with the features, quality, price and security needs of specific organisations. While the spectrum of such solutions is welcome and demonstrates the expanding nature of the market, it also makes it time consuming for IT managers to identify the appropriate system for their respective company needs. This paper provides a list of key management tools which include a minimum set of features, such as availability of secure database for managing keys, an authentication, authorization, and access control model for restricting and managing access to keys, effective logging of actions with keys, and the presence of an API for accessing functions directly from the application code. Five systems were comprehensively compared by evaluating the attributes related to complexity of the implementation, its popularity, linked vulnerabilities and technical performance in terms of response time and network usage. These were Pinterest Knox, Hashicorp Vault, Square Keywhiz, OpenStack Barbican, and Cyberark Conjur. Out of these five, Hachicorp Vault was determined to be the most suitable system for small businesses.