POD-based study of turbulent plane Poiseuille flow: comparing structure and dynamics between quasi-linear simulations and DNS

TL;DR

This study compares turbulence structures and dynamics in Poiseuille flow using POD analysis of DNS and RNL simulations, revealing similar coherent structures and self-sustaining mechanisms driven by optimal perturbation growth.

Contribution

It demonstrates that RNL dynamics captures key turbulence structures and mechanisms similar to DNS, validated through POD analysis and stochastic turbulence modeling.

Findings

POD modes show dominant spanwise harmonic roll-streaks in both DNS and RNL.

Structures include oblique waves associated with streaks, predicted by STM.

Self-sustaining turbulence mechanisms are similar in DNS and RNL, driven by optimal perturbations.

Abstract

Turbulence in the restricted nonlinear (RNL) dynamics is analyzed and compared with DNS of Poiseuille turbulence at $R=1650$. The structures are obtained by POD analysis of the two components of the flow partition used in RNL dynamics: the streamwise-mean flow and fluctuations. POD analysis of the streamwise-mean flow indicates that the dominant POD modes, in both DNS and RNL, are roll-streaks harmonic in the spanwise. However, we conclude that these POD modes do not occur in isolation but rather are Fourier components of a coherent roll-streak structure. POD analysis of the fluctuations in DNS and RNL reveals similar complex structures consisting in part of oblique waves collocated with the streak. The origin of these structures is identified by their correspondence to POD modes predicted using a stochastic turbulence model (STM). These predicted POD modes are dominated by the optimally growing structures on the streak, which the STM predicts correctly to be of sinuous oblique wave structure. This close correspondence between the roll-streak structure and the associated fluctuations in DNS, RNL and the STM implies that the self-sustaining mechanism operating in DNS is essentially the same as that in RNL, which has been previously associated with optimal perturbation growth on the streak.