Three-nodal surface phonons in solid-state materials: Theory and material realization

TL;DR

This paper predicts and identifies real materials hosting three-nodal surface phonons, expanding the understanding of topological phonon states through symmetry analysis and first-principles calculations.

Contribution

It extends the concept of topological phonons from one-nodal surface to three-nodal surface phonons and identifies specific materials hosting these states.

Findings

Nine candidate space groups hosting three-NS phonons.

Identification of specific materials with three-NS phonons.

Enrichment of the class of nodal surface states in phonon systems.

Abstract

This year, Liu \textit{et al}. [Phys. Rev. B \textbf{104}, L041405 (2021)] proposed a new class of topological phonons (TPs; i.e., one-nodal surface (NS) phonons), which provides an effective route for realizing one-NSs in phonon systems. In this work, based on first-principles calculations and symmetry analysis, we extended the types of NS phonons from one- to three-NS phonons. The existence of three-NS phonons (with NS states on the $k_{i}$ = $\pi$ ($i$ = $x$, $y$, $z$) planes in the three-dimensional Brillouin zone (BZ)) is enforced by the combination of two-fold screw symmetry and time reversal symmetry. We screened all 230 space groups (SGs) and found nine candidate groups (with the SG numbers (Nos.) 19, 61, 62, 92, 96, 198, 205, 212, and 213) hosting three-NS phonons. Interestingly, with the help of first-principles calculations, we identified $P2_{1}$2$_{1}$2$_{1}$-type YCuS$_{2}$ (SG No. 19), $Pbca$-type NiAs$_{2}$ (SG No. 61), $Pnma$-type SrZrO$_{2}$ (SG No. 62), $P4_{1}$2$_{1}$2-type LiAlO$_{2}$ (SG No. 92), $P4_{3}$2$_{1}$2-type ZnP$_{2}$ (SG No. 96), $P2_{1}$3-type NiSbSe (SG No. 198), $Pa\bar{3}$-type As$_{2}$Pt (SG No. 205), $P4_{3}$32-type BaSi$_{2}$ (SG No. 212), and $P4_{1}$32-type CsBe$_{2}$F$_{5}$ (SG No. 213) as realistic materials hosting three-NS phonons. The results of our presented study enrich the class of NS states in phonon systems and provide concrete guidance for searching for three-NS phonons and singular Weyl point phonons in realistic materials.