Replacing quarantine of COVID-19 contacts with periodic testing is also effective in mitigating the risk of transmission

TL;DR

This study uses a simulation model to show that periodic testing of COVID-19 contacts can effectively replace quarantine, reducing transmission risk even with limited testing resources and imperfect adherence.

Contribution

It introduces a simulation-based evaluation of sequential testing as an alternative to quarantine, highlighting cost-effective testing strategies for COVID-19 contact tracing.

Findings

Two LFA tests can match 14-day quarantine effectiveness with high adherence.

Adding a third test achieves the same reduction as a full 14-day quarantine.

Results are robust across different viral load models and test sensitivities.

Abstract

The quarantine of identified close contacts has been vital to reducing transmission rates and averting secondary infection risk before symptom onset and by asymptomatic cases. The effectiveness of this contact tracing strategy to mitigate transmission is sensitive to the adherence to quarantines, which may be lower for longer quarantine periods or in vaccinated populations (where perceptions of risk are reduced). This study develops a simulation model to evaluate contact tracing strategies based on the sequential testing of identified contacts after exposure as an alternative to quarantines, in which contacts are isolated only after confirmation by a positive test. The analysis considers different number and types of tests (PCR and lateral flow antigen tests (LFA)) to identify the cost-effective testing policies that minimize the expected infecting days post-exposure considering different levels of testing capacity. This analysis suggests that even a limited number of tests can be effective at reducing secondary infection risk: two LFA tests (with optimal timing) avert infectiousness at a level that is comparable to 14-day quarantine with 80-90% adherence, or equivalently, 7-9 day quarantine with full adherence (depending on the sensitivity of the LFA test). Adding a third test (PCR or LFA) reaches the efficiency of a 14-day quarantine with 90-100% adherence. These results are robust to the exposure dates of the contact, test sensitivity of LFA and alternative models of viral load evolution, which suggests that simple testing rules can be effective for improving contact tracing in settings where strict quarantine adherence is difficult to implement.