Early Stages of Flame Propagation in Tubes with No-slip Walls and the Mechanism of Tulip Flame Formation

TL;DR

This paper investigates the early development of tulip flames in tubes with no-slip walls, revealing that rarefaction waves and flow velocity changes drive the flame front inversion, independent of instabilities or vortex effects.

Contribution

It demonstrates that tulip flame formation is a purely gas-dynamic process driven by rarefaction waves, supported by simulations with simplified and detailed chemical models.

Findings

Rarefaction waves cause flame front inversion.

Flow velocity reduction facilitates tulip flame formation.

Mechanism is independent of vortex motion or instabilities.

Abstract

The early stages of flames propagation in tubes with no-slip walls and the inversion of the flame front from a convex shape directed towards unburned gas to a concave shape with a cusp directed to the burned gas, known as a tulip flame, was investigated for closed and half-open tubes by solving the fully compressible reactive Navier-Stokes equations with a one-step Arrhenius chemical model for the highly reactive hydrogen/air and slowly reacting methane/air mixtures. The development of the tulip flame in hydrogen/air obtained in simulations with a one-step Arrhenius model was compared with simulations using a detailed chemical model. It is shown that the inversion of the flame front and the onset of the tulip flame occurs due to rarefaction waves generated by the decelerating flame when its surface was reduced due to extinguishing of the rear parts of the flame skirt at the sidewalls. The rarefaction waves reduce the flow velocity ahead of the flame, creating an uneven velocity profile, which facilitate the flame front inversion. In the case of a flame propagating in a tube with both ends closed, the compression wave reflected from the tube end opposite to the ignition end, also contribute to the inversion of the flame front. In the case of fast flames and a relatively short tube with both closed ends, the rarefaction waves may invert the flow velocities in the unburned gas towards the propagating flame. The tulip flame formation mechanism is a purely gas-dynamic phenomenon not associated with flame instabilities or vortex motion, in agreement with the conclusion obtained in recent experimental studies [1].