The Ropelength of Complex Knots

TL;DR

This paper extends the understanding of knot ropelength by analyzing complex knots beyond previous crossing number limits, establishing new bounds, power-law scaling, and a predictive model based on Hopf links.

Contribution

It investigates knots with higher crossing numbers, provides stronger bounds for torus knots, and introduces a heuristic model for ropelength prediction without free parameters.

Findings

Established a stronger upper bound for T(p,2) knots and links.

Demonstrated power-law scaling in T(p,p+1) knots.

Satellite knots have approximately three times the ropelength of their companions.

Abstract

The ropelength of a knot is the minimum contour length of a tube of unit radius that traces out the knot in three dimensional space without self-overlap, colloquially the minimum amount of rope needed to tie a given knot. Theoretical upper and lower bounds have been established for the asymptotic relationship between crossing number and ropelength and stronger bounds have been conjectured, but numerical bounds have only been calculated exhaustively for knots and links with up to 11 crossings, which are not sufficiently complex to test these conjectures. Existing ropelength measurements also have not established the complexity required to reach asymptotic scaling with crossing number. Here, we investigate the ropelength of knots and links beyond the range of tested crossing numbers, past both the 11-crossing limit as well as the 16-crossing limit of the standard knot catalog. We investigate torus knots up to 1023 crossings, establishing a stronger upper bound for T(p,2) knots and links and demonstrating power-law scaling in T(p,p+1) below the proven limit. We investigate satellite knots up to 42 crossings to determine the effect of a systematic crossing-increasing operation on ropelength, finding that a satellite knot typically has thrice the ropelength of its companion. We find that ropelength is well described by a model of repeated Hopf links in which each component adopts a minimal convex hull around the cross-section of the others, and derive formulae that heuristically predict the crossing-ropelength relationship of knots and links without free parameters.