Stellar response after stripping as a model for common-envelope outcomes

TL;DR

This study models the final stages of the common-envelope phase in neutron star binary progenitors by simulating the response of stars after envelope stripping, revealing plausible boundaries for envelope ejection and potential hydrogen retention.

Contribution

It introduces a one-dimensional stellar evolution approach to identify plausible stripping boundaries and challenges the traditional core boundary location in common-envelope modeling.

Findings

Stripping boundaries are above the maximum compression point.

Stars may retain fractions of hydrogen-rich material post-envelope ejection.

Models suggest overfilling Roche lobe if only orbital energy is considered.

Abstract

Binary neutron stars have been observed as millisecond pulsars, gravitational-wave sources, and as the progenitors of short gamma-ray bursts and kilonovae. Massive stellar binaries that evolve into merging double neutron stars are believed to experience a common-envelope episode. During this episode, the envelope of a giant star engulfs the whole binary. The energy transferred from the orbit to the envelope by drag forces or from other energy sources can eject the envelope from the binary system, leading to a stripped short-period binary. In this paper, we use one-dimensional single stellar evolution to explore the final stages of the common-envelope phase in progenitors of neutron star binaries. We consider an instantaneously stripped donor star as a proxy for the common-envelope phase and study the star's subsequent radial evolution. We determine a range of stripping boundaries which allow the star to avoid significant rapid re-expansion and which thus represent plausible boundaries for the termination of the common-envelope episode. We find that these boundaries lie above the maximum compression point, a commonly used location of the core/envelope boundary. We conclude that stars may retain fractions of a solar mass of hydrogen-rich material even after the common-envelope episode. If we consider orbital energy as the only energy source available, all of our models would overfill their Roche lobe after ejecting the envelope, whose binding energy includes gravitational, thermal, radiation, and recombination energy terms.