On the Approximability of Multistage Min-Sum Set Cover

TL;DR

This paper studies the difficulty of approximating the multistage Min-Sum Set Cover problem, proving hardness results and providing approximation algorithms with factors of $O( ext{log}^2 n)$ and $O(r^2)$.

Contribution

It establishes hardness of constant-factor approximation and presents polynomial-time algorithms with $O( ext{log}^2 n)$ and $O(r^2)$ approximation ratios.

Findings

No $O(1)$-approximation unless P=NP.

An $O( ext{log}^2 n)$ approximation algorithm exists.

An $O(r^2)$ approximation algorithm exists for small request sizes.

Abstract

We investigate the polynomial-time approximability of the multistage version of Min-Sum Set Cover ($\mathrm{DSSC}$), a natural and intriguing generalization of the classical List Update problem. In $\mathrm{DSSC}$, we maintain a sequence of permutations $(\pi^0, \pi^1, \ldots, \pi^T)$ on $n$ elements, based on a sequence of requests $(R^1, \ldots, R^T)$. We aim to minimize the total cost of updating $\pi^{t-1}$ to $\pi^{t}$, quantified by the Kendall tau distance $\mathrm{D}_{\mathrm{KT}}(\pi^{t-1}, \pi^t)$, plus the total cost of covering each request $R^t$ with the current permutation $\pi^t$, quantified by the position of the first element of $R^t$ in $\pi^t$. Using a reduction from Set Cover, we show that $\mathrm{DSSC}$ does not admit an $O(1)$-approximation, unless $\mathrm{P} = \mathrm{NP}$, and that any $o(\log n)$ (resp. $o(r)$) approximation to $\mathrm{DSSC}$ implies a sublogarithmic (resp. $o(r)$) approximation to Set Cover (resp. where each element appears at most $r$ times). Our main technical contribution is to show that $\mathrm{DSSC}$ can be approximated in polynomial-time within a factor of $O(\log^2 n)$ in general instances, by randomized rounding, and within a factor of $O(r^2)$, if all requests have cardinality at most $r$, by deterministic rounding.