Examinations of CO completeness based on three independent CO surveys

TL;DR

This study compares three CO surveys of the Milky Way's outskirts, revealing that the total molecular gas mass is underestimated and more extensive structures are present than previously recognized, impacting our understanding of galactic baryonic matter.

Contribution

It provides a comparative analysis of three independent CO surveys, quantifies observational biases, and suggests a higher total molecular mass for the Galaxy.

Findings

MWISP detects more extended and unseen structures.

Total CO flux in MWISP is 1.6 times larger than other surveys.

Galactic H2 mass should be at least 40% higher than previous estimates.

Abstract

We report the global properties recovered by an ongoing CO survey of the Milky Way Imaging Scroll Painting (MWISP) toward the Galactic outskirts. %To better understand the observational biases, Our results are also compared to those extracted by a uniform decomposition method from the CfA 1.2 m CO survey and the FCRAO 14 m outer Galaxy survey (OGS). We find that more extended and unseen structures are present in the MWISP data. The total flux across the disk recovered by the MWISP survey is 1.6 times larger than those recovered by the CfA and OGS surveys in the case of the same resolution. The discrepancies are scaling with distance. For example, in the outermost OSC arm, the flux ratios for MWISP-to-CfA and MWISP-to-OGS increase up to 43.8 and 7.4, respectively. Nonetheless, the census of molecular gas in our Galaxy is still far from complete by the MWISP, with flux completeness of $<$58%. The total mass ratios of the tabulated molecular clouds between different surveys are similar to the CO flux ratio. The application of these ratios to the total H$_{\rm 2}$ mass of our Galaxy yields a correction factor of at least 1.4, meaning that the H$_{\rm 2}$ mass of our Galaxy should be at least 40% more massive than previously determined. Including the completeness correction, an even more significant fraction of the matter should be contributed by baryonic matter. The mass spectrum in the outer Galactic plane is better described by a non-truncating power-law with $\gamma$=$-$1.83$\pm$0.05, and an upper mass of $M_0$=(1.3$\pm$0.5)$\times$10$^{\rm 6}$ $M_\odot$.