On the Challenges of Open World Recognitionunder Shifting Visual Domains

TL;DR

This paper evaluates the effectiveness of open world recognition algorithms under domain-shift conditions, revealing significant performance drops and highlighting the need for more robust methods for real-world robotic vision.

Contribution

It introduces the first benchmark for assessing open world recognition under domain-shift and analyzes existing algorithms' limitations in such scenarios.

Findings

OWR algorithms perform poorly under domain-shift.

Domain generalization techniques only slightly improve performance.

Current methods are insufficient for reliable open world recognition in real-world conditions.

Abstract

Robotic visual systems operating in the wild must act in unconstrained scenarios, under different environmental conditions while facing a variety of semantic concepts, including unknown ones. To this end, recent works tried to empower visual object recognition methods with the capability to i) detect unseen concepts and ii) extended their knowledge over time, as images of new semantic classes arrive. This setting, called Open World Recognition (OWR), has the goal to produce systems capable of breaking the semantic limits present in the initial training set. However, this training set imposes to the system not only its own semantic limits, but also environmental ones, due to its bias toward certain acquisition conditions that do not necessarily reflect the high variability of the real-world. This discrepancy between training and test distribution is called domain-shift. This work investigates whether OWR algorithms are effective under domain-shift, presenting the first benchmark setup for assessing fairly the performances of OWR algorithms, with and without domain-shift. We then use this benchmark to conduct analyses in various scenarios, showing how existing OWR algorithms indeed suffer a severe performance degradation when train and test distributions differ. Our analysis shows that this degradation is only slightly mitigated by coupling OWR with domain generalization techniques, indicating that the mere plug-and-play of existing algorithms is not enough to recognize new and unknown categories in unseen domains. Our results clearly point toward open issues and future research directions, that need to be investigated for building robot visual systems able to function reliably under these challenging yet very real conditions. Code available at https://github.com/DarioFontanel/OWR-VisualDomains