Geometric Horizons: A Frame Approach

TL;DR

This paper introduces a null frame approach using the Cartan-Karlhede algorithm to identify geometric horizons in black hole mergers, focusing on algebraically special curvature properties and Cartan scalars for numerical relativity applications.

Contribution

It develops a null frame method with Cartan scalars to invariantly characterize geometric horizons during black hole mergers, enhancing numerical detection techniques.

Findings

Defined algebraically preferred null frame (APNF) for GH detection

Applied Cartan-Karlhede algorithm to fix null frame invariantly

Demonstrated method on axisymmetric Kastor-Traschen spacetime

Abstract

In the numerical investigation of the physical merger of two black holes, it is crucial to locate a black hole locally. This is usually done utilizing an apparent horizon. An alternative proposal is to identify a geometric horizon (GH), which is characterized by a surface in the spacetime on which the curvature tensor or its covariant derivatives are algebraically special. This necessitates the choice of a special null frame, which we shall refer to as an algebraically preferred null frame (APNF). The GH is then identified by surfaces of vanishing scalar curvature invariants but, unfortunately, these are difficult to compute. However, the algebraic nature of a GH means that the APNF plays a central role and suggests a null frame approach to characterizing the GH. Indeed, if we employ the Cartan-Karlhede algorithm to completely fix the null frame invariantly, then all of the remaining non vanishing components of the curvature tensor and its covariant derivatives are Cartan scalars. Hence the GH is characterized by the vanishing of certain Cartan scalars. A null frame approach is useful in the numerical investigation of the merger of two black holes in general, but we will focus on the application to identifying a GH. We begin with a review of the use of APNF and GH in previous work. The APNF is then defined and chosen so that the Weyl tensor is algebraically special, and we must examine the covariant derivatives of the Weyl tensor in this frame. We show how to invariantly fix the null frame, and hence characterize the APNF, and describe how to then identify the GH using the zero-set of certain Cartan scalars. Our ultimate aim is to apply this frame formalism to the numerical collapse of two black holes. As an example, we investigate the axisymmetric evolution of a two black hole Kastor-Traschen spacetime.