Light, medium-weight or heavy? The nature of the first supermassive black hole seeds

TL;DR

This study investigates the origins of supermassive black holes at high redshift, analyzing the roles of light, medium-weight, and heavy seeds, and finds that heavy seeds primarily drive SMBH growth through efficient gas accretion.

Contribution

First to analyze the relative importance of different seed populations in SMBH formation at z>6 using a semi-analytical model with spatial fluctuations and enrichment effects.

Findings

Heavy seeds dominate SMBH growth via gas accretion.

Medium-weight seeds have limited impact on SMBH evolution.

SMBH progenitors are a small fraction of early black hole population.

Abstract

Observations of hyper-luminous quasars at $z>6$ reveal the rapid growth of supermassive black holes (SMBHs $>10^9 \rm M_{\odot}$) whose origin is still difficult to explain. Their progenitors may have formed as remnants of massive, metal free stars (light seeds), via stellar collisions (medium-weight seeds) and/or massive gas clouds direct collapse (heavy seeds). In this work we investigate for the first time the relative role of these three seed populations in the formation of $z>6$ SMBHs within an Eddington-limited gas accretion scenario. To this aim, we implement in our semi-analytical data-constrained model a statistical description of the spatial fluctuations of Lyman-Werner (LW) photo-dissociating radiation and of metal/dust enrichment. This allows us to set the physical conditions for BH seeds formation, exploring their relative birth rate in a highly biased region of the Universe at $z>6$. We find that the inclusion of medium-weight seeds does not qualitatively change the growth history of the first SMBHs: although less massive seeds ($<10^3 \rm M_\odot$) form at a higher rate, the mass growth of a $\sim 10^9 \rm M_\odot$ SMBH at $z<15$ is driven by efficient gas accretion (at a sub-Eddington rate) onto its heavy progenitors ($10^5 \rm M_\odot$). This conclusion holds independently of the critical level of LW radiation and even when medium-weight seeds are allowed to form in higher metallicity galaxies, via the so-called super-competitive accretion scenario. Our study suggests that the genealogy of $z \sim 6$ SMBHs is characterized by a rich variety of BH progenitors, which represent only a small fraction ($< 10 - 20\%$) of all the BHs that seed galaxies at $z > 15$.