Competition between Born solvation, dielectric exclusion, and Coulomb attraction in spherical nanopores

TL;DR

This paper investigates how dielectric mismatch, Born solvation energy, and Coulomb attraction influence ion behavior in spherical nanopores, revealing their interplay affects ion exclusion, phase separation, and transport properties.

Contribution

It provides an analytical framework to understand the combined effects of dielectric mismatch, Born energy, and Coulomb forces on ions in nanopores, including phase diagrams and osmotic pressure signatures.

Findings

Dielectric mismatch significantly alters ion partitioning.

Born solvation energy impacts phase separation in confined geometries.

Electrostatic attraction and exclusion effects compete in charged nanopores.

Abstract

The recent measurement of a very low dielectric constant, $\epsilon$, of water confined in nanometric slit pores leads us to reconsider the physical basis of ion partitioning into nanopores. For confined ions in chemical equilibrium with a bulk of dielectric constant $\epsilon_b>\epsilon$, three physical mechanisms, at the origin of ion exclusion in nanopores, are expected to be modified due to this dielectric mismatch: dielectric exclusion at the water-pore interface (with membrane dielectric constant, $\epsilon_m<\epsilon$), the solvation energy related to the difference in Debye-H\"uckel screening parameters in the pore, $\kappa$, and in the bulk $\kappa_b$, and the classical Born solvation self-energy proportional to $\epsilon^{-1}-\epsilon_b^{-1}$. Our goal is to clarify the interplay between these three mechanisms and investigate the role played by the Born contribution in ionic liquid-vapor (LV) phase separation in confined geometries. We first compute analytically the potential of mean force (PMF) of an ion of radius $R_i$ located at the center of a nanometric spherical pore of radius $R$. Computing the variational grand potential for a solution of confined ions, we then deduce the partition coefficients of ions in the pore. Phase diagrams of the LV transition are established for various parameter values and we show that a signature of this phase transition can be detected by monitoring the total osmotic pressure. For charged nanopores, these exclusion effects compete with the electrostatic attraction that imposes the entry of counterions into the pore to enforce electro-neutrality. This study will therefore help in deciphering the respective roles of the Born self-energy and dielectric mismatch in experiments and simulations of ionic transport through nanopores.