Emergence as the conversion of information: A unifying theory

TL;DR

This paper introduces a unifying mathematical framework for emergence based on information conversion, demonstrating that macroscales can contain more of certain information types than microscales, challenging the idea of universal reduction in science.

Contribution

It provides a novel framework for understanding emergence through information conversion, using mutual information and partial information decomposition to show increased synergy at macroscales.

Findings

Macroscale can have more of a certain type of information than microscale.

Mutual information can be decomposed into redundant, unique, and synergistic parts.

Synergy in mutual information can increase at macroscales, indicating information conversion.

Abstract

Is reduction always a good scientific strategy? Does it always lead to a gain in information? The very existence of the special sciences above and beyond physics seems to hint no. Previous research has shown that dimension reduction (macroscales) can increase the dependency between elements of a system (a phenomenon called "causal emergence"). However, this has been shown only for specific measures like effective information or integrated information. Here, we provide an umbrella mathematical framework for emergence based on information conversion. Specifically, we show evidence that a macroscale can have more of a certain type of information than its underlying microscale. This is because macroscales can convert information from one type to another. In such cases, reduction to a microscale means the loss of this type of information. We demonstrate this using the well-understood mutual information measure applied to Boolean networks. By using the partial information decomposition, the mutual information can be decomposed into redundant, unique, and synergistic information atoms. Then by introducing a novel measure of the synergy bias of a given decomposition, we are able to show that the synergy component of a Boolean network's mutual information can increase at macroscales. This can occur even when there is no difference in the total mutual information between a macroscale and its underlying microscale, proving information conversion. We relate this broad framework to previous work, compare it to other theories, and argue it complexifies any notion of universal reduction in the sciences, since such reduction would likely lead to a loss of synergistic information in scientific models.