A novel approach to optimize the regularization and evaluation of dynamical models using a model selection framework

TL;DR

This paper introduces a model selection framework that accounts for model flexibility and optimizes regularization, significantly improving the accuracy of dynamical galaxy models in estimating properties like SMBH mass.

Contribution

It presents a novel approach to evaluate and select dynamical models by incorporating flexibility estimation and regularization optimization, reducing biases in galaxy property inference.

Findings

Improved accuracy in reconstructing galaxy mass, anisotropy, and viewing angle.

Successful application to real galaxy data, estimating inclination within 5 degrees.

Enhanced constraining power of orbit models with the new framework.

Abstract

Orbit superposition models are a non-parametric dynamical modelling technique to determine the mass of a galaxy's central supermassive black hole (SMBH), its stars, or its dark-matter halo. One of the main problems is how to decide which model out of a large pool of trial models based on different assumed mass distributions represents the true structure of an observed galaxy best. We show that the traditional approach to judge models solely by their goodness-of-fit can lead to substantial biases in estimated galaxy properties caused by varying model flexibilities. We demonstrate how the flexibility of the models can be estimated using bootstrap iterations and present a model selection framework that removes these biases by taking the variable flexibility into account in the model evaluation. We extend the model selection approach to optimize the degree of regularisation directly from the data. Altogether, this leads to a significant improvement of the constraining power of the modeling technique. We show with simulations that one can reconstruct the mass, anisotropy and viewing angle of an axisymmetric galaxy with a few percent accuracy from realistic observational data with fully resolved line-of-sight velocity distributions (LOSVDs). In a first application, we reproduce a photometric estimate of the inclination of the disk galaxy NGC 3368 to within 5 degree accuracy from kinematic data that cover only a few sphere-of-influence radii around the galaxy's SMBH. This demonstrates the constraining power that can be achieved with orbit models based on fully resolved LOSVDs and a model selection framework.