Critical processing temperature for high performance protected silver thin film mirrors

TL;DR

This study investigates how different annealing temperatures affect the optical performance and durability of protected silver mirrors used in astronomy, identifying an optimal temperature range for processing.

Contribution

It introduces a new benchmark for high-performance silver mirrors by analyzing the effects of annealing temperatures on their durability and optical properties.

Findings

Annealing below 200°C preserves mirror integrity after stress testing.

Annealing below 160°C maintains or improves spectral reflectivity.

Higher annealing temperatures above 200°C cause significant degradation due to grain growth.

Abstract

Silver (Ag) mirrors for astronomical telescopes consist of multiple metallic and dielectric thin films. Furthermore, the topmost surface of such Ag mirrors needs to be covered by a protection coating. While the protection coating is often deposited at room temperature and the entire mirrors are also handled at room temperature, various thin film deposition techniques offer protection coatings with improved characteristics when carried out at elevated temperatures. Thus, in this work, high-performance Ag mirrors were designed and fabricated with a new benchmark. The resulting Ag mirrors were annealed (i.e., post-fabrication annealing) at various temperatures to investigate the viability of introducing thermal processes during and/or after fabrication in improving overall optical performance and durability of protected silver mirrors. In our experiments, Ag mirror samples were deposited by electron-beam evaporation and subsequently annealed at various temperatures in the range from 60 {\deg}C to 300 {\deg}C, and then the mirror samples underwent an environmental stress test at 80 {\deg}C and 80% humidity for 10 days. While all the mirror samples annealed below 200 {\deg}C showed negligible corrosion after undergoing the stress testing, those annealed below 160 {\deg}C presented spectral reflectivity comparable to or higher than that of as-deposited reference samples. In contrast, the mirror samples annealed above 200 {\deg}C exhibited significant degradation after the stress testing. The comprehensive analysis indicated that delamination and voids caused by the growth of Ag grains during the annealing are the primary mechanisms of the degradation.