Pincer-Based vs. Same-Direction Strategies of Search for Smart Evaders by Swarms of Agents

TL;DR

This paper compares pincer-based and same-direction search strategies for detecting smart evaders using swarms of agents, demonstrating that pincer strategies outperform in search time and critical speed requirements.

Contribution

It introduces and analyzes pincer-movement search strategies, proving their superiority over same-direction methods in terms of efficiency and speed constraints.

Findings

Pincer strategies have lower total search times than same-direction strategies.

Spiral pincer sweep can detect all evaders at near-optimal speeds.

Pincer strategies require a lower critical speed for successful search.

Abstract

Suppose in a given planar region, there are smart mobile evaders and we want to detect them using sweeping agents. We assume that the agents have line sensors of equal length. We propose procedures for designing cooperative sweeping processes that ensure successful completion of the task, thereby deriving conditions on the sweeping speed of the agents and their paths. Successful completion of the task means that evaders with a known limit on their speed cannot escape the sweeping agents. A simpler task for the sweeping swarm is the confinement of the evaders to their initial domain. The feasibility of completing these tasks depends on geometric and dynamic constraints that impose a lower bound on the speed the sweeping agent must have. This critical speed is derived to ensure the satisfaction of the confinement task. Increasing the speed above the lower bound enables the agents to complete the search task as well. We present a quantitative and qualitative comparison analysis between the total search time of same-direction sweep processes and pincer-movement search strategies. We evaluate the different strategies by using two metrics, total search time and the minimal critical speed required for a successful search. We compare two types of pincer-movement search processes, circular and spiral, with their same-direction counterparts, for any even number of sweeping agents. We prove that pincer based strategies provide superior results in all practical scenarios and that the spiral pincer sweep process allows detection of all evaders while sweeping at nearly theoretically optimal speeds.