Nonparametric Method for Clustered Data in Pre-Post Factorial Design

TL;DR

This paper introduces nonparametric effect-size measures for clustered data in pre-post factorial designs, providing robust analysis without parametric assumptions, especially useful for non-metric data like Quality of Life outcomes.

Contribution

The paper develops novel nonparametric effect-size estimators and ANOVA-type tests for clustered pre-post data, accommodating incomplete clusters and arbitrary dependence structures.

Findings

Effective in multiple clustering scenarios

Provides asymptotic confidence intervals and hypothesis tests

Illustrated with a randomized trial on indoor wood smoke reduction

Abstract

In repeated measures factorial designs involving clustered units, parametric methods such as linear mixed effects models are used to handle within subject correlations. However, assumptions of these parametric models such as continuity and normality are usually hard to come by in many cases. The homoscedasticity assumption is rather hard to verify in practice. Furthermore, these assumptions may not even be realistic when data are measured in a non-metric scale as commonly happens, for example, in Quality of Life outcomes. In this article, nonparametric effect-size measures for clustered data in factorial designs with pre-post measurements will be introduced. The effect-size measures provide intuitively-interpretable and informative probabilistic comparisons of treatment and time effects. The dependence among observations within a cluster can be arbitrary across treatment groups. The effect-size estimators along with their asymptotic properties for computing confidence intervals and performing hypothesis tests will be discussed. ANOVA-type statistics with $\chi^2$ approximation that retain some of the optimal asymptotic behaviors in small samples are investigated. Within each treatment group, we allow some clusters to involve observations measured on both pre and post intervention periods (referred to as complete clusters), while others to contain observations from either pre or post intervention period only (referred to as incomplete clusters). Our methods are shown to be, particularly effective in the presence of multiple forms of clustering. The developed nonparametric methods are illustrated with data from a three-arm Randomized Trial of Indoor Wood Smoke reduction. The study considered two active treatments to improve asthma symptoms of kids living in homes that use wood stove for heating.