Multi-spacecraft observations of coronal loops to verify a force-free field reconstruction and infer loop cross sections

TL;DR

This study uses multi-viewpoint observations to test the accuracy of a magnetic field reconstruction method for coronal loops, revealing complexities in loop cross sections and challenging the assumption of circularity.

Contribution

It provides observational validation of a 3D magnetic field reconstruction method using multiple spacecraft perspectives, highlighting the prevalence of non-circular loop cross sections.

Findings

69.5% of loops matched structures from different viewpoints

Lack of correlation suggests loops may have elliptical or complex cross sections

Anti-correlation between brightness and diameter supports elliptical cross sections

Abstract

Active region EUV loops are believed to trace a subset of magnetic field lines through the corona. Malanushenko et al. (2009) proposed a method, using loop images and line-of-sight photospheric magnetograms, to infer the three-dimensional shape and field strength along each loop. McCarthy et al. (2019) used this novel method to compute the total magnetic flux interconnecting a pair of active regions observed by SDO/AIA. They adopted the common assumption that each loop had a circular cross section. The accuracy of inferred shape and circularity of cross sections can both be tested using observations of the same loops from additional vantage points as provided by STEREO/EUVI. Here, we use multiple viewing angles to confirm the three-dimensional structure of loops. Of 151 viable cases, 105 (69.5%) matched some form of visible coronal structure when viewed approximately in quadrature. A loop with a circular cross-section should appear of a similar width in different perspectives. In contradiction to this, we find a puzzling lack of correlation between loop diameters seen from different perspectives, even an anti-correlation in some cases. Features identified as monolithic loops in AIA may, in fact, be more complex density enhancements. The 30.5% of reconstructions from AIA which did not match any feature in EUVI might be such enhancements. Others may be genuine loop structures, but with elliptical cross sections. We observe an anti-correlation between diameter and brightness, lending support to the latter hypothesis. Of 13 suitable for width analysis, four loops are consistent with non-circular cross sections, where we find anti-correlation in both comparisons.