When Can Liquid Democracy Unveil the Truth?

TL;DR

This paper analyzes the computational complexity of the ODP problem in liquid democracy, demonstrating hardness results, proposing approximation algorithms under certain conditions, and showing through simulations that liquid democracy can outperform direct democracy.

Contribution

It provides new hardness bounds for ODP, introduces conditions for effective approximation, and empirically compares liquid democracy with direct democracy.

Findings

Hardness of approximation for ODP under certain conditions

Connectivity of social networks influences algorithm efficiency

Simple algorithms outperform direct democracy in simulations

Abstract

In this paper, we investigate the so-called ODP-problem that has been formulated by Caragiannis and Micha [10]. Here, we are in a setting with two election alternatives out of which one is assumed to be correct. In ODP, the goal is to organise the delegations in the social network in order to maximize the probability that the correct alternative, referred to as ground truth, is elected. While the problem is known to be computationally hard, we strengthen existing hardness results by providing a novel strong approximation hardness result: For any positive constant $C$, we prove that, unless $P=NP$, there is no polynomial-time algorithm for ODP that achieves an approximation guarantee of $\alpha \ge (\ln n)^{-C}$, where $n$ is the number of voters. The reduction designed for this result uses poorly connected social networks in which some voters suffer from misinformation. Interestingly, under some hypothesis on either the accuracies of voters or the connectivity of the network, we obtain a polynomial-time $1/2$-approximation algorithm. This observation proves formally that the connectivity of the social network is a key feature for the efficiency of the liquid democracy paradigm. Lastly, we run extensive simulations and observe that simple algorithms (working either in a centralized or decentralized way) outperform direct democracy on a large class of instances. Overall, our contributions yield new insights on the question in which situations liquid democracy can be beneficial.