Boolean function metrics can assist modelers to check and choose logical rules

TL;DR

This paper introduces Boolean function metrics to help biological modelers evaluate and select logical rules, ensuring their biological plausibility and improving model accuracy in complex signaling networks.

Contribution

It links semantic Boolean function characterization with biological plausibility, proposing metrics to analyze rule impact and guide logical operator choices in biological models.

Findings

Boolean function bias correlates with regulatory outcomes

Metrics identify biologically implausible rules

Rule specification influences network dynamics

Abstract

Computational models of biological processes provide one of the most powerful methods for a detailed analysis of the mechanisms that drive the behavior of complex systems. Logic-based modeling has enhanced our understanding and interpretation of those systems. Defining rules that determine how the output activity of biological entities is regulated by their respective inputs has proven to be challenging, due to increasingly larger models and the presence of noise in data, allowing multiple model parameterizations to fit the experimental observations. We present several Boolean function metrics that provide modelers with the appropriate framework to analyze the impact of a particular model parameterization. We demonstrate the link between a semantic characterization of a Boolean function and its consistency with the model's underlying regulatory structure. We further define the properties that outline such consistency and show that several of the Boolean functions under study violate them, questioning their biological plausibility and subsequent use. We also illustrate that regulatory functions can have major differences with regard to their asymptotic output behavior, with some of them being biased towards specific Boolean outcomes when others are dependent on the ratio between activating and inhibitory regulators. Application results show that in a specific signaling cancer network, the function bias can be used to guide the choice of logical operators for a model that matches data observations. Moreover, graph analysis indicates that the standardized Boolean function bias becomes more prominent with increasing numbers of regulators, confirming the fact that rule specification can effectively determine regulatory outcome despite the complex dynamics of biological networks.