Variational Principles in Teleparallel Gravity Theories

TL;DR

This paper investigates the variational principles and derivation of field equations in various teleparallel gravity theories, demonstrating their equivalence across different geometric formulations and discussing implications of diffeomorphism invariance.

Contribution

It clarifies the equivalence of different variational approaches in teleparallel gravity and analyzes the role of geometric constraints and invariance properties.

Findings

All approaches yield the same field equations.

Different formulations and constraints are equivalent.

Diffeomorphism invariance relates gravitational field equations.

Abstract

We study the variational principle and derivation of the field equations for different classes of teleparallel gravity theories, using both their metric-affine and covariant tetrad formulations. These theories have in common that in addition to the tetrad or metric, they employ a flat connection as additional field variable, but differ by the presence of absence of torsion and nonmetricity for this independent connection. Besides the different underlying geometric formulation using a tetrad or metric as fundamental field variable, one has different choices to introduce the conditions of vanishing curvature, torsion and nonmetricity, either by imposing them a priori and correspondingly restricting the variation of the action when the field equations are derived, or by using Lagrange multipliers. Special care must be taken, since these conditions form non-holonomic constraints. Here we show explicitly that all of the aforementioned approaches are equivalent, and that the same set of field equations is obtained, independently of the choice of the geometric formulation and variation procedure. We further discuss consequences arising from the diffeomorphism invariance of the gravitational action, and show how they establish relations between the gravitational field equations.