Hubble spectroscopy of LB-1: comparison with B+black-hole and Be+stripped-star models

TL;DR

This study uses Hubble spectroscopy and Gaia data to compare two models of LB-1, a binary system, evaluating their spectral fits and stellar parameters to determine the more plausible configuration and properties.

Contribution

The paper provides a detailed spectral analysis of LB-1, comparing B+black-hole and Be+stripped-star models with new Hubble data, refining stellar parameters and assessing model fits.

Findings

The Be+Bstr model fits optical HeI and Balmer lines better.

The B+BH model fits UV Si iv resonance lines better.

The Bstr star shows high silicon abundance, challenging its stripped star origin.

Abstract

LB-1 has variously been proposed as either an X-ray dim B-type star plus black hole (B+BH) binary, or a Be star plus an inflated stripped star (Be+Bstr) binary. The Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph (STIS) on board HST was used to obtain a flux-calibrated spectrum that is compared with non-LTE spectral energy distributions (SED) and line profiles for the proposed models. The Hubble data, together with the Gaia EDR3 parallax, provide tight constraints on the properties and stellar luminosities of the system. In the case of the Be+Bstr model we adopt the published flux ratio for the Be and Bstr stars, re-determine the T$_{eff}$ of the Bstr using the silicon ionization balance, and infer Teff for the Be star from the fit to the SED. We derive stellar parameters consistent with previous results, but with greater precision enabled by the Hubble SED. While the Be+Bstr model is a better fit to the HeI lines and cores of the Balmer lines in the optical, the B+BH model provides a better fit to the Si iv resonance lines in the UV. The analysis also implies that the Bstr star has roughly twice solar silicon abundance, difficult to reconcile with a stripped star origin. The Be star on the other hand has a rather low luminosity, and a spectroscopic mass inconsistent with its possible dynamical mass. The fit to the UV can be significantly improved by reducing the T$_{eff}$ and radius of the Be star, though at the expense of leading to a different mass ratio. In the B+BH model, the single B-type spectrum is a good match to the UV spectrum. Adopting a mass ratio of 5.1$\pm$0.1 (Liu et al. 2020) implies a BH mass of $\sim$21$^{+9}_{-8}M_{\odot}$.