Who Invented the Trinity Nuclear Test's Christy Gadget? Patents and Evidence from the Archives

TL;DR

This paper investigates the origin of the Christy Gadget used in the Trinity nuclear test, analyzing archival evidence to clarify whether Robert Christy or Rudolf Peierls initially proposed the design, ultimately attributing primary credit to Christy.

Contribution

The study presents new archival evidence from Los Alamos archives to resolve historical disputes over the invention of the Christy Gadget, confirming Christy's primary role.

Findings

Archival evidence supports Christy as the originator of the design.

Christy and Peierls share joint patent credit, but Christy led the invention.

Additional contributions from von Neumann and others are acknowledged.

Abstract

The Christy Gadget is the informal name for the plutonium device detonated in the Trinity test on July 16, 1945. In September 1944, Robert Christy, working in the theoretical implosion group, proposed a novel concept that altered the design of the nuclear core in Fat Man. While scientists originally intended to use a hollow sphere of plutonium, this design entailed substantial risk, due to the likelihood of asymmetries resulting from implosion. Christy proposed changing the design to a solid sphere of plutonium with a modulated neutron source, and the design was eventually adopted, tested at Trinity, and used in the attack on Nagasaki. While there is no question regarding the important role that Christy played in demonstrating its feasibility as a reliable design, there is a debate as to who initially proposed the idea; though most sources have attributed this invention to Christy, some historical sources have attributed credit to Christy's group leader, Rudolf Peierls, or indeed other scientists. This paper seeks to outline and resolve this dispute. We present new unclassified evidence extracted from previously unavailable sources (to unclassified audiences) from the National Security Research Center archives at Los Alamos National Laboratory. This evidence consists of 1945-1946 patent documentation, oral history interview tapes of Christy and Peierls, and monthly 1944 progress reports from the Theoretical Division. Though Christy and Peierls share joint credit on the patent, both Christy's and Peierls' words and writings, together with sources from Hans Bethe and Edward Teller, support the traditional view that Christy was indeed the originator of the idea. While Christy does deserve the majority of the credit for the invention and design, we acknowledge the important role Peierls and von Neumann played in its development.