Technical Leverage in a Software Ecosystem: Development Opportunities and Security Risks

TL;DR

This paper investigates the concept of technical leverage in the FOSS ecosystem, introducing metrics to measure dependency evolution, and finds that higher leverage correlates with increased security vulnerabilities and development benefits.

Contribution

It introduces novel metrics to quantify dependency leverage and analyzes their implications on security and development in the FOSS ecosystem.

Findings

Small and medium libraries have higher dependency leverage.

Leverage increases development efficiency with minimal delay.

Higher leverage libraries are more prone to security vulnerabilities.

Abstract

In finance, leverage is the ratio between assets borrowed from others and one's own assets. A matching situation is present in software: by using free open-source software (FOSS) libraries a developer leverages on other people's code to multiply the offered functionalities with a much smaller own codebase. In finance as in software, leverage magnifies profits when returns from borrowing exceed costs of integration, but it may also magnify losses, in particular in the presence of security vulnerabilities. We aim to understand the level of technical leverage in the FOSS ecosystem and whether it can be a potential source of security vulnerabilities. Also, we introduce two metrics change distance and change direction to capture the amount and the evolution of the dependency on third-party libraries. The application of the proposed metrics on 8494 distinct library versions from the FOSS Maven-based Java libraries shows that small and medium libraries (less than 100KLoC) have disproportionately more leverage on FOSS dependencies in comparison to large libraries. We show that leverage pays off as leveraged libraries only add a 4% delay in the time interval between library releases while providing four times more code than their own. However, libraries with such leverage (i.e., 75% of libraries in our sample) also have 1.6 higher odds of being vulnerable in comparison to the libraries with lower leverage. We provide an online demo for computing the proposed metrics for real-world software libraries available under the following URL: https://techleverage.eu/.