Evaluation and Optimization of Distributed Machine Learning Techniques for Internet of Things

TL;DR

This paper empirically compares federated, split, and splitfed learning on Raspberry Pi IoT devices, analyzing their performance, overhead, and proposing optimizations to improve efficiency and scalability.

Contribution

It provides the first real-world comparison of FL, SL, and SFL on IoT devices and introduces a generalized SFL with hybrid training and communication reduction techniques.

Findings

SL outperforms FL under imbalanced data but worse under extreme non-IID data.

Optimizations reduce communication overhead by up to four times.

Generalized SFL improves scalability for large IoT systems.

Abstract

Federated learning (FL) and split learning (SL) are state-of-the-art distributed machine learning techniques to enable machine learning training without accessing raw data on clients or end devices. However, their \emph{comparative training performance} under real-world resource-restricted Internet of Things (IoT) device settings, e.g., Raspberry Pi, remains barely studied, which, to our knowledge, have not yet been evaluated and compared, rendering inconvenient reference for practitioners. This work firstly provides empirical comparisons of FL and SL in real-world IoT settings regarding (i) learning performance with heterogeneous data distributions and (ii) on-device execution overhead. Our analyses in this work demonstrate that the learning performance of SL is better than FL under an imbalanced data distribution but worse than FL under an extreme non-IID data distribution. Recently, FL and SL are combined to form splitfed learning (SFL) to leverage each of their benefits (e.g., parallel training of FL and lightweight on-device computation requirement of SL). This work then considers FL, SL, and SFL, and mount them on Raspberry Pi devices to evaluate their performance, including training time, communication overhead, power consumption, and memory usage. Besides evaluations, we apply two optimizations. Firstly, we generalize SFL by carefully examining the possibility of a hybrid type of model training at the server-side. The generalized SFL merges sequential (dependent) and parallel (independent) processes of model training and is thus beneficial for a system with large-scaled IoT devices, specifically at the server-side operations. Secondly, we propose pragmatic techniques to substantially reduce the communication overhead by up to four times for the SL and (generalized) SFL.