BAT99-9 -- a WC4 Wolf-Rayet star with nitrogen emission: Evidence for binary evolution?

TL;DR

This study investigates the nitrogen-rich WC4 Wolf-Rayet star BAT99-9 in the LMC, analyzing its spectral features and evolutionary history to determine if it resulted from single or binary star evolution.

Contribution

The paper provides the first detailed spectral analysis of BAT99-9, showing intrinsic nitrogen lines, and compares observations with single and binary evolution models to explore its origin.

Findings

BAT99-9 shows unambiguous photospheric nitrogen features.

Single star models at Galactic metallicity can produce similar N/C ratios.

Binary evolution models also explain the observed nitrogen enrichment.

Abstract

An analysis of the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) WC4 star BAT99-9 (HD 32125, FD 4, Brey 7, WS 3) shows that the star still contains photospheric nitrogen. Three N emission features (N V $\lambda\lambda 1238,1242$, N IV $\lambda 1719$, N IV $\lambda\lambda 3479 - 3485$) are unambiguously identified in the spectrum. CMFGEN models of the star yield a N/C ratio of $0.004 \pm 0.002$ (by number) and a C/He ratio of $0.15_{-0.05}^{+0.10}$. Due to the similarity of BAT99-9 to other WC4 stars, and the good fit achieved by CMFGEN to both the classic WC4 spectrum, and the N lines, we argue that the N lines are intrinsic to BAT99-9. An examination of a limited set of rotating models for single star evolution at LMC and Galactic metallicities shows that a model with a Galactic metallicity ($z=0.014$) and a progenitor mass of around $50\,M_\odot$ can have a N/C ratio similar to, or larger than, what we observe for a significant fraction of its lifetime. However, the LMC models ($z=0.006$) are inconsistent with the observations. Both the single and binary BPASS models predict that many WC stars can have a N/C ratio similar to, or larger than, what we observe for a significant fraction of their lifetime. While the binary models cover a wider range of luminosities and provide a somewhat better match to BAT99-9, it is not currently possible to rule out BAT99-9 being formed through single star evolution, given the uncertainties in mass-loss rates, and the treatment of convection and mixing processes.