Tornado-Like Vortices in the Quasi-Cyclostrophic Regime of Coriolis-Centrifugal Convection

TL;DR

This paper uses numerical simulations of Coriolis-centrifugal convection to identify the conditions under which tornado-like vortices form, revealing the importance of centrifugal buoyancy and the quasi-cyclostrophic regime in tornadogenesis.

Contribution

It demonstrates that centrifugal buoyancy in a quasi-cyclostrophic regime is crucial for the self-consistent formation of tornado-like vortices in a simplified cylindrical model.

Findings

TLVs share features with real tornadoes, such as velocity profiles and helicity.

TLV formation depends on the Froude number exceeding the aspect ratio, Fr > γ.

A critical mesocyclone rotation rate of ~3×10^{-2} s^{-1} is identified for tornadogenesis.

Abstract

Coriolis-centrifugal convection (C$^3$) in a cylindrical domain constitutes an idealised model of tornadic storms, where the rotating cylinder represents the mesocyclone of a supercell thunderstorm. We present a suite of C$^3$ direct numerical simulations, analysing the influence of centrifugal buoyancy on the formation of tornado-like vortices (TLVs). TLVs are self-consistently generated provided the flow is within the quasi-cyclostrophic (QC) regime. This requires the Froude number to be greater than the radius-to-height aspect ratio, $Fr \gtrsim \gamma$. We show that the TLVs share many features with realistic tornadoes, such as azimuthal velocity profiles, intensification of the vortex strength, and helicity characteristics. Further, we analyse the influence of the mechanical bottom boundary conditions on the formation of TLVs, finding that a rotating fluid column above a stationary surface does not generate TLVs if centrifugal buoyancy is absent. In contrast, TLVs are generated in the QC regime with any bottom boundary conditions when centrifugal buoyancy is present. Our simulations bring forth insights into natural supercell thunderstorm systems by identifying properties that determine whether a mesocyclone becomes tornadic or remains non-tornadic. Our $Fr \gtrsim \gamma$ predictions dimensionally imply a critical mesocyclone angular rotation rate of $\widetilde{\Omega}_{mc} \gtrsim \sqrt{g/H_{mc}}$. Taking a typical mesocyclone height of $H_{mc}\approx 12$ km, this translates to $\widetilde{\Omega}_{mc}\gtrsim 3~\times~10^{-2}$s$^{-1}$ for centrifugal buoyancy-dominated, quasi-cyclostrophic tornadogenesis. The formation of the simulated TLVs happens at all heights on the centrifugal buoyancy time scale $\tau_{cb}$. This implies a roughly 1 minute, height-invariant formation for natural tornadoes, consistent with recent observational estimates.