Resolution of the spin paradox in the Nilsson model

TL;DR

This paper resolves the spin paradox in Nilsson diagrams by introducing a new quantum number correspondence rule, aligning proton and neutron energy levels without altering the diagram's shape.

Contribution

A new rule for quantum number correspondence in Nilsson diagrams is proposed, resolving the spin paradox and ensuring consistent proton-neutron level labeling.

Findings

The spin paradox in Nilsson diagrams is resolved.

Proton and neutron diagrams are now in full agreement.

The shape of the Nilsson diagrams remains unchanged.

Abstract

In the well-known Nilsson diagrams, depicting the dependence of the nuclear single-particle energy levels on quadrupole deformation, a spin paradox appears {as the deformation sets in, leading from spherical shapes to prolate deformed shapes with cylindrical symmetry}. Bunches of levels corresponding to a spherical shell model orbital, sharing the same orbital angular momentum and the same total angular momentum, appear to correspond to Nilsson energy levels, labeled by asymptotic quantum numbers in cylindrical coordinates, some of which have spin up, while some others have spin down. Furthermore, for some orbitals the correspondence between spherical shell model quantum numbers and Nilsson asymptotic quantum numbers is not the same for protons and for neutrons. Introducing a new rule of correspondence between the two sets of quantum numbers, we show that the spin paradox is resolved and full agreement between the proton and neutron Nilsson diagrams is established. The form of the Nilsson diagrams as a function of the quadrupole deformation remains unchanged, the only difference between the new diagrams and the traditional ones being the mutual exchange of the Nilsson labels for certain pairs of single-particle energy levels.