On Optimizing the Trade-off between Privacy and Utility in Data Provenance

TL;DR

This paper formalizes the tradeoff between privacy and utility in data provenance, proposing an optimization framework and heuristics to balance disclosure and confidentiality of query information.

Contribution

It introduces a novel formalization of provenance abstraction for privacy-utility tradeoff and develops practical heuristics for optimizing this balance.

Findings

Heuristic algorithms effectively balance privacy and utility in provenance data.

Experimental results demonstrate the approach's effectiveness on benchmark datasets.

The formalization provides a new perspective on privacy-preserving data provenance.

Abstract

Organizations that collect and analyze data may wish or be mandated by regulation to justify and explain their analysis results. At the same time, the logic that they have followed to analyze the data, i.e., their queries, may be proprietary and confidential. Data provenance, a record of the transformations that data underwent, was extensively studied as means of explanations. In contrast, only a few works have studied the tension between disclosing provenance and hiding the underlying query. This tension is the focus of the present paper, where we formalize and explore for the first time the tradeoff between the utility of presenting provenance information and the breach of privacy it poses with respect to the underlying query. Intuitively, our formalization is based on the notion of provenance abstraction, where the representation of some tuples in the provenance expressions is abstracted in a way that makes multiple tuples indistinguishable. The privacy of a chosen abstraction is then measured based on how many queries match the obfuscated provenance, in the same vein as k-anonymity. The utility is measured based on the entropy of the abstraction, intuitively how much information is lost with respect to the actual tuples participating in the provenance. Our formalization yields a novel optimization problem of choosing the best abstraction in terms of this tradeoff. We show that the problem is intractable in general, but design greedy heuristics that exploit the provenance structure towards a practically efficient exploration of the search space. We experimentally prove the effectiveness of our solution using the TPC-H benchmark and the IMDB dataset.