3D4ALL: Toward an Inclusive Pipeline to Classify 3D Contents

TL;DR

This paper proposes a human-in-the-loop pipeline using augmented learning for transparent and fair moderation of sensitive 3D content, emphasizing stakeholder diversity and metadata redesign for responsible sharing.

Contribution

It introduces a novel pipeline combining augmented learning and stakeholder input for 3D content moderation, addressing transparency, fairness, and responsible sharing.

Findings

Analyzed existing text/image-based moderation efforts.

Identified 3D-specific features for content moderation.

Proposed metadata redesign for responsible sharing.

Abstract

Algorithmic content moderation manages an explosive number of user-created content shared online everyday. Despite a massive number of 3D designs that are free to be downloaded, shared, and 3D printed by the users, detecting sensitivity with transparency and fairness has been controversial. Although sensitive 3D content might have a greater impact than other media due to its possible reproducibility and replicability without restriction, prevailed unawareness resulted in proliferation of sensitive 3D models online and a lack of discussion on transparent and fair 3D content moderation. As the 3D content exists as a document on the web mainly consisting of text and images, we first study the existing algorithmic efforts based on text and images and the prior endeavors to encompass transparency and fairness in moderation, which can also be useful in a 3D printing domain. At the same time, we identify 3D specific features that should be addressed to advance a 3D specialized algorithmic moderation. As a potential solution, we suggest a human-in-the-loop pipeline using augmented learning, powered by various stakeholders with different backgrounds and perspectives in understanding the content. Our pipeline aims to minimize personal biases by enabling diverse stakeholders to be vocal in reflecting various factors to interpret the content. We add our initial proposal for redesigning metadata of open 3D repositories, to invoke users' responsible actions of being granted consent from the subject upon sharing contents for free in the public spaces.