Overcoming bias in representational similarity analysis

TL;DR

This paper proposes a partial correlation method to reduce bias in representational similarity analysis (RSA) for functional imaging, addressing confounds from non-orthogonal design matrices and autocorrelation, with demonstrated effectiveness on real data.

Contribution

It introduces a data-driven partial correlation approach to mitigate bias in RSA, accounting for autocorrelation and non-orthogonality, and provides publicly available software implementation.

Findings

Partial correlation reduces bias in RSA.

Local bias impact is minor in real data.

Limitations arise where autocorrelation diverges from estimates.

Abstract

Representational similarity analysis (RSA) is a multivariate technique to investigate cortical representations of objects or constructs. While avoiding ill-posed matrix inversions that plague multivariate approaches in the presence of many outcome variables, it suffers from the confound arising from the non-orthogonality of the design matrix. Here, a partial correlation approach will be explored to adjust for this source of bias by partialling out this confound in the context of the searchlight method for functional imaging datasets. A formal analysis will show the existence of a dependency of this confound on the temporal correlation model of the sequential observations, motivating a data-driven approach that avoids the problem of misspecification of this model. However, where the autocorrelation locally diverges from its volume estimate, bias may be difficult to control for exactly, given the difficulties of estimating the precise form of the confound at each voxel. Application to real data shows the effectiveness of the partial correlation approach, suggesting the impact of local bias to be minor. However, where the control for bias locally fails, possible spurious associations with the similarity matrix of the stimuli may emerge. This limitation may be intrinsic to RSA applied to non-orthogonal designs. The software implementing the approach is made publicly available (https://github.com/roberto-viviani/rsa-rsm.git).