The role of resonant plasma instabilities in the evolution of blazar induced pair beams

TL;DR

This paper investigates the development of resonant plasma instabilities in blazar-induced pair beams, concluding that such instabilities are unlikely to significantly drain the beam's energy due to the narrow opening angles of extragalactic beams.

Contribution

The study provides a comprehensive analytical and numerical analysis showing that resonant plasma instabilities are ineffective in dissipating energy in narrow extragalactic pair beams.

Findings

Parallel wave growth rates are higher than oblique waves.

Narrow beam opening angles suppress resonance growth.

Beam energy remains largely unaffected by instabilities.

Abstract

The fate of relativistic pair beams produced in the intergalactic medium by very high energy emission from blazars remains controversial in the literature. The possible role of resonance beam plasma instability has been studied both analytically and numerically but no consensus has been reached. In this paper, we thoroughly analyze the development of this type of instability. This analysis takes into account that a highly relativistic beam loses energy only due to interactions with the plasma waves propagating within the opening angle of the beam (we call them parallel waves), whereas excitation of oblique waves results merely in an angular spreading of the beam, which reduces the instability growth rate. For parallel waves, the growth rate is a few times larger than for oblique ones, so they grow faster than oblique waves and drain energy from the beam before it expands. However, the specific property of extragalactic beams is that they are extraordinarily narrow; the opening angle is only $\Delta\theta\sim 10^{-6}-10^{-5}$. In this case, the width of the resonance for parallel waves, $\propto\Delta\theta^2$, is too small for them to grow in realistic conditions. We perform both analytical estimates and numerical simulations in the quasilinear regime. These show that for extragalactic beams, the growth of the waves is incapable of taking a significant portion of the beam's energy. This type of instability could at best lead to an expansion of the beam by some factor but the beam's energy remains nearly intact.