Hierarchical fragmentation in high redshift galaxies revealed by hydrodynamical simulations

TL;DR

This study uses high-resolution hydrodynamical simulations to reveal that high-redshift galaxies contain hierarchical structures, with small gas clusters forming within larger complexes, explaining observational biases against detecting giant clumps.

Contribution

It demonstrates that giant star-forming clumps are composed of smaller clusters within larger complexes, and explains why they are often missed in high-resolution observations.

Findings

Giant clumps are formed by smaller gas clusters within larger complexes.

High-resolution observations may miss the hierarchical structure, leading to non-detection of giant clumps.

Simulated giant clumps can be gravitationally bound even if not detected in mock observations.

Abstract

High-redshift star-forming galaxies have very different morphologies compared to nearby ones. Indeed, they are often dominated by bright star-forming structures of masses up to $10^{8-9}$ $\mathrm{M}_\odot$ dubbed {\guillemotleft}giant clumps{\guillemotright}. However, recent observations questioned this result by showing only low-mass structures or no structure at all. We use Adaptative Mesh Refinement hydrodynamical simulations of galaxies with parsec-scale resolution to study the formation of structures inside clumpy high-redshift galaxies. We show that in very gas-rich galaxies star formation occurs in small gas clusters with masses below $10^{7-8}$ $\mathrm{M}_\odot$ that are themselves located inside giant complexes with masses up to $10^8$ and sometimes $10^9$ $\mathrm{M}_\odot$. Those massive structures are similar in mass and size to the giant clumps observed in imaging surveys, in particular with the Hubble Space Telescope. Using mock observations of simulated galaxies, we show that at very high resolution with instruments like the Atacama Large Millimeter Array or through gravitational lensing, only low-mass structures are likely to be detected, and their gathering into giant complexes might be missed. This leads to the non-detection of the giant clumps and therefore introduces a bias in the detection of these structures. We show that the simulated giant clumps can be gravitationally bound even when undetected in mocks representative for ALMA observations and HST observations of lensed galaxies. We then compare the top-down fragmentation of an initially warm disc and the bottom-up fragmentation of an initially cold disc to show that the process of formation of the clumps does not impact their physical properties.