Thermodynamics of $d$-dimensional Schwarzschild black holes in the canonical ensemble

TL;DR

This paper extends the thermodynamic analysis of Schwarzschild black holes to any number of dimensions within a canonical ensemble, revealing stability criteria, phase transitions, and the role of the Buchdahl radius.

Contribution

It generalizes York's formalism to d dimensions, analyzes stability and phase transitions, and links classical and quantum thermodynamics of black holes in a unified framework.

Findings

Large black holes are thermodynamically stable.

Small black holes are unstable and prone to phase transitions.

The Buchdahl radius determines the nucleation of black holes from hot flat space.

Abstract

We study the thermodynamics of a $d$-dimensional Schwarzschild black hole in the canonical ensemble. This generalizes York's formalism to any number $d$ of dimensions. The canonical ensemble, characterized by a cavity of fixed radius $r$ and fixed temperature $T$ at the boundary, allows for two possible solutions in thermal equilibrium, a small and a large black hole. From the Euclidean action and the path integral approach, we obtain the free energy, the thermodynamic energy, the pressure, and the entropy, of the black hole plus cavity system. The entropy is given by the Bekenstein-Hawking area law. The heat capacity shows that the smaller black hole is in unstable equilibrium and the larger is stable. The photon sphere radius divides the stability criterion. To study perturbations, a generalized free energy function is obtained that allows to understand the possible phase transitions between classical hot flat space and the black holes. The Buchdahl radius, that appears naturally in the general relativistic study of star structure, also shows up in our context, the free energy is zero when the cavity's radius has the Buchdahl radius value. Then, if the cavity's radius is smaller than the Buchdahl radius classical hot flat space can nucleate a black hole. It is also pointed out the link between the canonical analysis performed and the direct perturbation of the path integral. Since gravitational hot flat space is a quantum system made purely of gravitons it is of interest to compare the free energies of quantum hot flat space and the stable black hole to find for which ranges of $r$ and $T$ one phase predominates over the other. Phase diagrams are displayed. The density of states at a given energy is found. Further calculations and comments are carried out, notably, a connection to thin shells in $d$ spacetime dimensions which are systems that are also apt to rigorous thermodynamics.